Photographers in the Archive · No. 01

Solomon D. Butcher.

Burton, Virginia, 1856 — Greeley, Colorado, 1927

In archive
0
Active
1886 — c. 1911
Theatre
Nebraska · Yellowstone · Pine Ridge

The life

Solomon Devore Butcher arrived in Custer County, Nebraska in 1880, filed on a homestead, and almost immediately decided he did not want to farm it. What he wanted, by his own account, was to make a photographic record of the people who did — the families breaking sod across the central plains in the last decades of the nineteenth century.

From roughly 1886 through 1892 he travelled the county with a wagon-mounted view camera, posing homesteaders in front of their sod houses with everything they owned arranged on the prairie: organs, sewing machines, wedding-china, mule-deer antlers, the milk cow, the horse, the dog, the rifle. The resulting plates — perhaps three thousand of them — are the most complete visual record of frontier sod-house life that survives anywhere in America.

The work was nearly lost. A 1899 fire destroyed his studio and negatives of his manuscript history; the glass plates survived only because they were stored in a separate building. The Nebraska State Historical Society acquired the surviving negatives in 1911 and they remain the cornerstone of any serious study of the homesteading era.

Butcher kept working into the new century. By the late 1900s he had moved into the real-photo postcard trade and was operating in and around the Pine Ridge Reservation, photographing Lakota encampments, dances, and the everyday cultural collisions of Rushville and White Clay. He died in Greeley, Colorado in 1927, largely poor, his reputation made entirely by other people's later reading of his pictures.

A note on these holdings

Butcher's reputation rests primarily on the sod-house work of 1886–1892. The Cranford Rare archive currently holds a single sod-house plate alongside a deeper run of his later real-photo postcards — the 1904 and 1909 Yellowstone trips, and the 1907–1909 work out of Callaway, Rushville, Pine Ridge, and the Black Hills. More sod-house material is in the gallery's possession and awaiting scanning; this page will grow as those plates are catalogued.

Back to the archive